The sluggish labour market suggests the economy is not recovering, or at best weakly and society is suffering — especially NEETs .
The labour market is one of the most important interfaces between the economy and society. Unfortunately, too often the analysis of the macroeconomy just reports on the unemployment rate and does not tease out its social implications. Yet the unemployment rate – the headline when statistics on the labour market are released – is subject to various deficiencies.
For instance, consider a group of 100 teens, 98 of whom are in full-time education, one has a job, one is looking for a job. Their official unemployment rate is a whopping 50 percent because the unemployment rate is the ratio between the numbers unemployed and those in employment and unemployment. Most people would think the statistic misled one’s understanding of the actual situation of teenagers.
While it is generally accepted that Māori unemployment is more serious than non-Māori unemployment – typically their rate is about double the national average. In September 2026 it was 10.9% compared to 5.5% for all New Zealanders. But that statistic neglects that Māori are more likely to have abandon looking for work and so are classified as ‘not in the labour force’. Were they to actively seek jobs – one factor is that if the unemployed get knocked back too often, they stop looking – at the same rate as the national average, their unemployment rate would be at an even more serious three times the national average rate – 17.0% in September 2026. (There are more unemployed Pakeha than Māori – because there are more Pakeha.)
Analysis becomes even more complicated, when it recognises that the international definition of employment includes persons employed for only one hour per week. Suppose they want more hours but are unable to find them – just like a fully unemployed person. That effect is captured in the ‘underutilisation rate’ which is currently over two-and-a-half times the unemployment rate.
One could go on, but to summarise, analysing the labour market is more complex that headlining the unemployment rate every three months and then forgetting about it.
We give little attention to the NEETs – Not in Employment, Education or Training. Despite the reverse of the acronym, the age group usually covers 15-24-year-olds. All ages are important, but this is the time when individuals move from the sheltering of childhood into full membership of adulthood. A critical part of that socialisation is working.
In September 2026, the age group was about 690, 000 people, of whom 91,000 were NEETs – that is, 13.2%. (And yes, rates for Māori and Pasifika are about double that for Pakeha.) They can be grouped as follows:
About 38,000 were unemployed, seeking work in the labour force but not in education or training;
Another 11,000 were caring for others – mainly mothers with young children (a declining proportion, as women delay the age when they have their children). *
The residual 42,000-odd were neither in the labour force, caring for others, nor in education and training. That would include those too sick to work (the indications are that psychological distress is rising sharply in the age group), those in the black economy, those skiving and those taking a break.
The residual NEETs – almost half of the total – are a bit of a dark hole both to public knowledge and policy. Insofar as the unemployed NEETs are on benefits, they are a policy concern but is more about getting them off the public payroll. If you are not getting a benefit, we are not interested in you. Once you have left school, we have no further interest in your human development.
Should we be concerned with people in the late socialisation phase? I raise the issue tentatively, and then withdraw. Economists have no particular expertise in socialisation. That we all had an adolescence (and many have struggled – or are struggling – with their children’s adolescence) allows us to have strong opinions expressed in uninformed public debate.
It is puzzling though that while NEET was coined 30 years ago, it hardly appears in the New Zealand public vocabulary. (Statistics New Zealand has been monitoring them for almost 20 years).
My interest was piqued by NZCTU Economic Bulletin addressing NEETs in its October/November 2026 issue. As you might expect in an organisation which is concerned with the interface between the economy society, their report begins with the labour market. Hence its concerns with NEETs.
The analysis raises a more immediate issue: ‘What recovery?’ The sentiment promoted by the government and endorsed by many in the commentariat is that the economy is finally undergoing an expansion. It is true that labour market indicators are among the last to turn around (because at first employers expand output by taking up the slack of workers they have chosen not to layoff). There are highlights in some regions and some industries, but other regions have been struggling and there are still firms closing down or laying off workers (not just from the public sector).
The indicators of labour market health – such as the unemployment rate, the utilisation rate, the NEET rate ... – have been relentlessly upward since September 2022. Filled jobs – employment numbers have been flat and are still lower than they were in September 2023. Inflation is down, but so are real (inflation-adjusted) incomes.
I offer the following interpretations:
– there is no recovery;
– it is a jobless recovery;
– it is a very weak recovery.
We shall have to wait a few more quarters to decide.
It is salutary that while on these measures the economy looked weaker this 2026 election than the 2023 last. One might conclude that the economy was not dominating voters’ intentions, but they were saying it did. So why did it not result in a more significant swing to the opposition parties?
The cynic might say that while the young were being most hurt by the economy, they were discouraged from enrolling, and that those who enrolled were discouraged from voting, either consciously or because no party seemed to be addressing their issues. Is there room for a Cockroach Party in New Zealand?
* The statistical convention is not to classify mothers as employed, even though looking after young children is a full-time job albeit one with appalling working conditions and poor pay.