And so the saga of the Brash email invesigations ends, not with a bang, but with continued denials by those exposed

When my book The Hollow Men was published over three years ago, the National Party-aligned PR man Matthew Hooton wrote a furious newspaper column saying that the source material for the book had obviously been illegally hacked and that he and others were going to investigate and bring me to justice. Time has proved him wrong on both points.

Egged on by Hooton, former National Party leader Don Brash complained to the police about my leaked materials, prompting a long police investigation. The police, predictably, found no evidence of hacking or crime. Instead of accepting these findings, Hooton accused the police of political bias and he, Brash and a small set of right-wing commentators demanded a new police inquiry. Under this angry criticism, the police launched a high-level second investigation.  A total of three years of police investigation ended last week and, despite all those wasted police resources, the conclusion was once again that hacking was "highly unlikely".

As the newspapers reported, the police found no evidence of “hacking of any sort, no evidence of any interception or use of similar devices. No evidence of anything, really – in fact there was absolutely no trail to follow.” Adding in all the evidence, they wrote, "the chances of illegal electronic entry become more remote. The general consensus is that this was not the manner in which the emails were obtained." Elsewhere in the report they said they were "confident that the Parliamentary computer was not hacked" and that "there was no evidence to implicate Mr Hager as having committed a criminal offence in obtaining and publishing the emails and documents."

For everyone except the grumpy cabal who pushed for the police investigation, this was the end of the matter. But before forgetting about the whole thing, the release of the police report gives an interesting political snapshot.

You probably haven't seen the two police reports (they weren't released on the Internet) but they are pleasingly detailed and unambiguous. I don't think anyone who reads them will give any credibility to Hooton and cos original allegations of hacking and crime. This makes the responses from Brash, Hooton and other National Party figures (who would presumably have seen the reports) all the more interesting.

The first person to comment was Hooton, using his Monday morning commentator spot on Radio New Zealand. You would hope that a news organisation, where he had previously loudly aired his views about hacking and stolen e-mails, would have put it to Hooton that the police had found no evidence to support his allegations. Alas no. Instead Hooton, the PR man, simply scooted around the fact that he'd been proven wrong and came up with a new and even more far fetched allegation. "The only strange thing about it," he said, "was that there was some information in the book that only could have come from [National Party donor] Diane Foreman's home, and couldn't have come from Parliament and that's still unresolved." Sigh. It does not reflect well on Radio New Zealand that they continue to employ this shameless spin doctor as a commentator.

The next person to respond to the police finding was John Key, at his weekly Monday afternoon press conference. This was disturbing in a different way. Leaving aside that some press gallery journalists seemed primarily interested that the prime minister had said a rude word ("bollocks"), the remarkable thing was that a three year investigation by police professionals had made no impression on Key at all. The insight that this small event gives into the mind of the prime minister is that he didn't just dodge the unpalatable information like Hooton, he simply didn't believe information that didn't suit him. Thus his conclusion, at the end of a police inquiry that disproved the hacking theory as comprehensively as was possible, was to tell the reporters that he believed the parliamentary computers had been hacked "but I can't back that up". Maybe this is how things are in the world of currency trading that he comes from: there's no such thing as solid fact or principle; everything is fluid and adjustable.

A few other people made similar comments, repeating the now familiar claims about hacked parliamentary computers and theft. The joke is that this short list of people had something rather obvious in common. Pretty well all the people proclaiming that there had been wrong doing were people who had been exposed in my book doing what I described as dishonest, dodgy or manipulative things themselves. Don Brash, John Key, Matthew Hooton (PR adviser to Brash), Richard Long (chief spin doctor for Brash) and John Ansell (advertising consultant to Brash). They naturally felt hurt and angry about their secret actions and discussions being revealed to the public.

But for three years they have turned this on its head and painted themselves as the victims – avoiding responsibility for their own actions and attacking me for exposing them. For all but the utterly partisan and self interested, the police investigation should at last have put an end to that.

*For further insight into the emails debate and Nicky's discussion of how they were sourced, see here.

Comments (11)

by stuart munro on March 19, 2010
stuart munro

All of which tends to obscure the real issue: that National party leaders illegally and secretly conspired to make an end run around electoral finance rules.

And Labour, when they were caught, let them off, because the integrity of our democratic system is not a priority for them.

Had the emails been hacked, the perpetrator should be fined. But the National and Exclusive Brethren conspirators should have hanged.

by Bruce Thorpe on March 22, 2010
Bruce Thorpe

To be fair to Labour, Stuart, it was an open and shut legal case and if it had been I think Labour would have pursued it.

It was there efforts to close such doors that resulted in the EFA that caused Labour so much grief from media and ACT party activists

by stuart munro on March 23, 2010
stuart munro

Labour caused itself its own grief on the issue. They wanted a bob each way, so they let the hollowmen wriggle off the hook.

They should have hanged, notwithstanding Palmer's little alteration to the treason laws in preparation for the indefensible disposal of public assets.

by Red Tussock on April 05, 2010
Red Tussock

No doubt the real villain is sensationalist journalism that made the whole story grow and grow, just like Pinnochios nose, it all got a bit out of control eh Nicky. Any server admin knows how copies of emails can be lifted without trace ... the sad thing is that we have a police force that lack the ability to nab the vindictive little pricks that carried out the crime.

by Mr Smith on June 18, 2010
Mr Smith

Great work Nicky, as usual the national supporters are trying to distract people from the fact the national party are a bunch of deceitful hollow men,  Anyone that read your book (The Hollow Men) can only applaud you for showing what goes on behind the false public image of this party .

by jack on December 01, 2011
jack

I am wondering if it was John Key who had given the order for those emails to end up in your lap.  He has no integrity.   I haven't read the book but since John Key has been Prime Minister,  his actions say opposite with what he promised.  I still can't believe it, he has flipped flopped so many times but the public still trust him!

by on March 07, 2012
Anonymous

Typically the shoes with regard to ball always have pure cotton shoelaces so that it won’t start through activity. Thus, you should always acquire Mercurial Victory all those Nike Air Force One, which will fit with your intent

by on May 08, 2012
Anonymous

 

At this time the Polo Outlet shirts accomplish a accidental seems but in accession can appoint a person's angel instead top quality.Ralph Lauren Outlet For example,Polo ralph Lauren shirt-spun1,polo ralph lauren, you could see Polo tee shirts accepting activated for abode of T-shirts with the authority out to bear the abnormally actual abundant way added accountant appears to be like after accepting any gluttonous as able-bodied relaxed,Ralph Lauren Polo shirt-spun1,ralph lauren polo, as a end up aftereffect creating a academy seek acutely absolutely abundant added all set if accepting activated by employees. Ralph Lauren Men Shirts

by on May 17, 2012
Anonymous

From the design point of view, the NC200D the main structure is more compact, beats by dr dre,ear muffs can be flipped,dr dre beats solo hd.beat by dre solo hd. beat dr dre.the inside of the flush design, the use of low-resilience polyurethane foam material, the machine with the battery weighs only about 180g, very comfortable to wear. It also can go to the inside of folding, beat by dre solo hd.facilitate the admission in a portable box. beat dr dre.Somic friends always ask the headset sound quality and product highlights technologies since the exposure of the new HiFi Headphones chart.beats by dre solo hd. beats by dre solo hd.As the headset sales ranked first Somic, beats solo hd.has been combined with electro-acoustics bond, baptism after EFi82pro, MH463 audio market, and then stepped up the pace of pushing better quality headphones. Today, I get further information for this HiFi headset.beats dre solo hd. Recalling the earlier exposure map, beat by dre.this HIFI headphones shape than before MH463 domineering, model named the MH489.beats solo hd. Address some of the details of the first beam to wear or headphones, we can see has been carefully designed. solo hd beats by dre.Look at the picture of the latest exposure of the entire headset in black and red mix to impact the entire visual passion in listening at the same time but without losing the sense of enjoyment. monster solo hd.Part of the first beam with a metal frame wrapped in a layer of soft plastic, beats dre solo hd.you can feel in his hand there is a soft feeling. The location of the first beam is loaded decompression headgear sponge with scale to adjust the stretch frame custom user comfort needs.

by Jonathan Plowman on June 02, 2013
Jonathan Plowman

I believe this fellow would have had something to do with the Brash email thefts. Makes for interesting reading at any rate.

http://www.whaleoil.co.nz/2009/05/is-this-the-man-behind-the-brash-email...

by Philip Grimmett on January 02, 2014
Philip Grimmett

Thank you Nicky,  for your ongoing work. I am saddened at the direction of NZ, and I admire your integrity. 

Heartening to know that a few independent journalists are trying to hold the powerful to account in NZ. 

 

Post new comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.