As the bloodshed increases and the desperation intensifies, it is time to ask what is the ultimate aim of the bombardment of Gaza, and how will the international community stop each side from harming the innocents of the other.

As the Israeli-Palestinian crisis deepens and the number of dead rises, two urgent questions need to be answered. What is the ultimate aim of Israel’s overwhelming bombardment of people it has caged in effectively the world’s largest open air prison – Gaza - and if the aim is the destruction of its democratically elected Hamas leadership, who will assume control of that parlous strip of land?

Few issues incite such division as this volatile part of the Middle East. Palestinians themselves are divided between Hamas and Fatah, Jews and Arabs are divided, Christians Jews and Muslims are divided, and politicians the word over tend to tread very carefully for fear of being labeled anti-Semitic or anti-Muslim. Even within countries such as the United States which for inexplicable reasons seems tied to all things Israeli, populations are divided.

Within Israelitself it is not only the Israeli Jews and substantial Israeli Arab populations that do not see eye to eye. Young Israeli Jews are in prison for refusing compulsory military conscription because they oppose Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians – like 19-yr-old Omer Goldman, whose former MOSSAD director father now refuses to acknowledge her.

No person nor state should be expected to tolerate the sort of rocket fire that Hamas has inflicted on Israel’s southern towns, but to use that as the excuse for the collective punishment by indiscriminate slaughter of inhabitants of Gaza should not be tolerated either.

Of the countless cliché’s that come to mind, two highly relevant to both parties in this disaster must be ‘violence begets violence’ and ‘two wrongs do not make a right’.

As Israeli politicians announce their Jewish constituents have been united by the fear of Hamas rockets, so too have Gazans found a new unity in the fight against Israel which they blame for the slow starvation of their 1.5 million fenced in on the Gaza strip.

Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni is quite right to assert that her people are sick and tired of hearing the air-raid sirens warning of incoming rockets. Her argument flounders however when she and fellow politicians hold Israel has a right to respond by use of violence because that violence is in the form of wholesale attacks on the innocents in one of the most densely populated areas in the world. It is impossible to ‘shock and awe’ Gaza without hitting disproportionately those amongst the 85% who live in refugee camps more than half of whom are children.

Ms Livni and others seem incapable of grasping the concept that if Israelis are permitted the luxury of violent reactions, then surely that is something Palestinians as fellow human beings are also are entitled to.

Israel does feel threatened, but it doesn’t take much brain power to see that years of repression of Palestinians through occupation, blockades of essential goods and fencing them in has fuelled a sense of hatred and resistance. Hamas, and for that matter Hizbollah did not exist until the early 1980s. Hamas surely draws support from a concept of action even if it results in a faster death over a slow death by blockade.

Desperation – such as there currently being no fresh drinking water in Gazaand no possible escape – brings out the she-lion instincts in humans, or to add another cliché, desperate people do desperate things. Pummeling such people into submission has never worked permanently and will not work this time.

Instead what is likely to happen is a new version of the disastrous 2006 offensive on Hizbollah. Israelhad to withdraw and Hizbollah was widely seen as victorious, not because it had defeated Israelper-se, but it had managed to stand up to the region’s military Goliath without being destroyed. Hamas remains on the path to a similar ‘victory’.

Now having unleashed the dogs of war on Gaza, Israel must be wondering what to do next.

Perhaps its main backer, the United States, can offer some lessons from its offensives in Korea, Vietnam, Somalia, Iraq or Afghanistan.

All the military might in the world becomes a problem rather than a solution unless fighting an equally matched opponent, or being hellbent on total destruction of an enemy nation.

The Cold War nuclear standoff between the USA and the Soviet Union remains the gold standard on the deterrence effect of equally matched opponents. The USA didn’t even dare to use its nuclear arsenal on North Korea nor North Vietnam as they were essentially Soviet proxies and a nuclear strike would result in nukes flying back across the Atlantic.

In Somalia, Iraq and Afghanistan the world’s military superpower has been drawn in to guerrilla warfare where the locals had/have the advantage.

Israel, having run out of strategic military targets in Gaza faces the same conundrum – what to do with its vastly superior weaponry, let alone its nukes. Israelcould hardly relish the concept of being bogged down in the labyrinth of enemy refugee camps in a ground offensive to destroy Hamas leadership. Its soldiers were outsmarted in Lebanon and have already shot four of their own in Gaza.

So back to the original questions.

If Israelmeasures success in the bombardment of Gazans into submission it will surely succeed in an own goal by further emboldening the so-called ‘Arab Street’.

Inadvertently Israel would assist in the return to power of the hard line regime in its most powerful regional enemy, Iran. President Ahmadinejad, up for re-election in June, is currently looking for every reason possible to enhance his popularity through a nationalistic cry for nuclear capability. Renewed ‘evidence’ of Israel’s oppressor status would play right into Ahmadinejad’s hands.

And the other issue: in the unlikely event of the total defeat of Hamas, what then?

Israel will not want to re-occupy Gazabut what would be its logical exit point? It is difficult indeed to imagine Gazans welcoming Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas as the saviour should Israelsucceed in clearing out Hamas and hand over the territory. The problem of course being that Palestinians are split in two and Palestinian Authority and/or Fatah arriving in Gaza essentially on the back of an Israeli tank could result in civil war.

The Middle-East has often been referred to as a powder keg. Such a description seems strangely benign as the shelling, the fear, the tiny white shrouds held by grieving parents, the utter despair, the bloodshed, the unthinkable destruction, and the calculation of it all fill television, radio and newspaper reports.

Shalom and Salaam are the Hebrew and Arabic words for peace. They are dramatically under-utilised and await a true commitment to an over-used ‘s’ word, ‘solution’. A solution requires good will on both sides to achieve a cessation of Hamas rocket fire on innocent Israelis, but also of Israeli oppression of innocent Palestinians.

Like every other world problem it seems this too will confront Barack Obama in little over a week. It is to be hoped there is something left to salvage – another underutilised ‘s’ word.

Comments (7)

by Adolf Fiinkensein on January 09, 2009
Adolf Fiinkensein

When you grow up, you might realise that the whole problem would disappear if Hamas and their Iranian handlers would recognises that Israel has a right to exist and to not be bombarded indesriminately with missiles for nine years at a a stretch.

by J Keenan on January 11, 2009
J Keenan

Adolf, it is that exact absolutist rhetoric that you have just used that sees this situation so deadlocked.

Both sides have contributed to this problem and both sides have legitmate grievences, it is extremely childish of you (and anyone else) to strongly support only one side of this nightmare.

by Adolf Fiinkensein on January 12, 2009
Adolf Fiinkensein

On the contrary, J Keenan.  It has been noted by people more experienced and erudite than me that Israel more than once has offered a compromise whereby a Palestinian state could exist but the Arab world has said no because there was a precondition.  A simple one really.  Recognise Israel's right to exist.  Now go and read the charter of Hamas and see what they have to say about that.

Simply put, they and their sponsors are the modern day Nazis of the Middle East.  You might care to study the relationship Yasser Arafat and his anticedents had with Hitler, Himler and Goebels.  Note well the Grand Mufti's escorted tour of Auschwitz and Belsen and his nixing of a prisoner exchange which would have saved 500 Jewish children.

So please don't insult me with your accusation of childishness when your own misguided wish to somehow be 'even handed' in the face of evil marks you as a modern day Chamberlain or worse, a Mosley.

by J Keenan on January 13, 2009
J Keenan

So Hamas in no way draws support from Israeli state force/terror? The like of which is happening right now?

In your comment what exactly has Yasser Arafat have to do with this current situation and Hamas in general?

One simple pre condition..? Okay so tell us all please Adolf in what from and with what boundaries does Israel have the right to exist? And when you have answered that "simple" question do you really believe that it would have universal backing? Not just opposition from the Arab world (which in your mind seems to be irrelevant) but support from the cross section of Israeli political opinion?

"Even handed" (ness) is the only way to confront a problem with legitamte grievences on both sides and I'll more than happlily stand by that and those who advocate for it as long as you sit in the G.W. Bush, D. Rumsfeld school of good vs evil and unilateral state force, aka the "neo-con wet dream".

I get the feeling though you would be quite happy in those dirty sheets 

by on May 08, 2012
Anonymous

Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet If the a lot of simple summer said dressed up, is a bargain Polo Outlet T-shirt with a brace of jeans that go out, both for the accessibility simple, do not breach afresh fashion, a lot of time become abounding adorableness who aboriginal choice;Polo Ralph Lauren Sale Look simple bargain POLOT the T-shirt with jeans, in fact in the Polo T-shirt selected, is aswell charge a lot of mind! Today let Ralph Lauren Men accouterment baby accomplish up for all the girls acclaim a nice and clear bargain Polo T-shirt, let your absorbing a summer!

by on May 18, 2012
Anonymous

people are pursuing for Louis vuitton handbags cool, unique, stylish and innovative. Whether it is discount Louis Vuitton or fashion accessories all means a lot for modern society of today. Same is the case with trendy looking burberry handbags. When these are, the excitement just gets doubled. Most chic looking burberry outlet are in fashion now. These are one of the favorite fashion abercrombie and fitch sale accessories for men and women long time ago. If you have not yet tried Louis Vuitton Outlet, it's time to own one and feel the difference it can make burberry bags to your personality. These are just brilliant and fabulous louis vuitton sale . They are most iconic and can provide burberry bags you with a new feeling and enhance confidence. The quality of louis vuitton online is just superior to what you have dreamt of. Today owning a new and trendy looking louis vuitton bagsare not only meant for the wealthy people. They are most iconic and can provide you with a new feeling and enhance abercrombie and fitch online confidence. The quality of abercrombie sale is just superior to what you have dreamt of. Today owning a new and trendy looking abercrombie outlet sale are not only meant for the wealthy people.

by on May 18, 2012
Anonymous

The newest style of Coach Purses Outlet offer ferragamo bags online. Coach Outlet have cheap Coach Diaper Bags, Coach Hobos Handbags ferragamo handbags, Coach Totes Handbags, Coach Outlet Online for cheap, Coach Poppy Handbags, Coach Outlet Online and Coach wallets. Coach Tote Bags are one of the most popular and versatile handbag styles.are well received by the females, especially the young. Stylish design, colorful painting, practical function attract the public's attention soon. All ferragamo outlet we offer here are stylish trims and innovative designs. Coach Outlet Store Online are mostly welcomed and loved by women and even men. Cheap Coach handbags use the unique and fine leather material which is extraordinary in the world. Take your time to select ferragamo sale our best Coach bags cheap for sale with discount wholesale and free and fast shipping. Online register as a member on this website and enjoy your online shopping. Welcome to enjoy shopping our salvatore ferragamo outlet! Our aim is Best quality top service. Just take action! Don't miss the opportunity to own one of these fasionable Discount Coach Handbags on discounted price. Free shipping and non sale tax! Buy ferragamo shoes now and enjoy the fashion world!

Post new comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.