Stories of the EU "overhauling" its farm subsidies are coming off the wires today. If only they were true

If you have a herd of cows and a flock of sheep, what's the collective term for the mass of conflicting news stories coming out today on the meeting of EU farm minister in Brussels overnight debating the future of Europe's archaic farm subsidies? A gaggle? A cloud? A murmuration?

The BBC is reporting that the ministers have agreed to shift subsidies further away from production and to liberalise the dairy market. The International Herald Tribune has described the deal as an "overhaul" representing "the biggest reform of European farming policy in five years", while Melbourne's Age calls it a "revamp". According to the IHT:

The measures, which cover the period from now to 2013, are aimed at revamping a decades-old system in which farmers automatically earned money for farm products whether there was market demand or not.

The Age says:

The changes expand on major CAP reforms in 2003, pushing European farmers further into the world of supply and demand with a smaller safety net of subsidies linked to production levels.

Specifically, the measures include dropping the rule that farmers must keep 10 percent of their land fallow and a gradual rise in milk quotas until they disappear in 2015. Subsidies for tobacco are cut, while other funding goes more towards conservation and regional development.

It looks like progress, but before we here in New Zealand go into our usual squeals of excitement at any freeing of global trade, there's a swarm of skepticism being reported as well.

For a start it's worth noting that the French pushed through this deal. And the general rule of thumb is that if it's good for the French, it's bad for us. The French Agriculture minister, for example, is still insisting that milk quotas won't be scrapped without "precautions being taken", saying the agreement gave European farmers more protection and offered more balance in government support to different types of farmers. So much for supply and demand. Around 40 percent of the EU's budget goes into the complex and corrupt Common Agricultural Policy. It's worth around nine billion Euros for France alone.

The Daily Telegraph says pro-reform Britain, which wouldn't support the deal, was out manoeuvred by France. It points to a "back door" measure that will allow countries to recycle unspent farm subsidy cash worth several hundred million dollars direct to farmers. Its story included this comment:

Peter Kendall, President of the National Union of Farmers, criticised talks that were "less of a health check, more of a further fix for addicts of distorting measures". "While some of the measures move us forward to our goal of a simpler, more level and more market focused CAP, others lead in precisely the opposite direction," he said.

Under the headline "France’s sneaky plans to continue Europe’s farming follies", the Economist is probably the most scathing about where these reform conversations are headed. After the G20's call to re-start the Doha trade round and given the global recession, France especially is under immense pressure to liberalise. Nicolas Sarkozy is not impressed, mais non.

But the French also know that the political costs of blocking a trade deal have risen. It would give the next American administration “all kinds of excuses” to water down other multilateral plans to save the world.

So it is forming a defensive huddle, looking to concede some policies to the open market, but demanding cash and some protection post-2013 in return. A French policy paper doing the rounds – it's unclear whether this was the paper voted on overnight or not, as the Economist story seems to pre-date the announcement –  still favours "community preference" of EU crops, "market stabilisation" (the public purchase of food is prices drop) and maintaining "regional cohesion" (ie, preserving farms in every French province, even if they're not economically viable).

Really, it remains a terribly confused picture. All the talk of dealing to this recession and helping emerging countries emerge further still comes to a grinding halt when it comes to those blasted French farmers (and all the other European vested interests they stand for).

We seem to be getting tiny gestures of liberalisation to give the impression of movement, while most of the loot stays clasped firmly to the farmers' chests. Perhaps it's nothing more than a plague of news stories.

Comments (5)

by Adolf Fiinkensein on November 23, 2008
Adolf Fiinkensein

You're absolutely right.

I sat on a flight out of Dunedin in 1983 and listened to a Dutch executive telling me how European tax payers were sick of supporting peasant farmers by way of subsidies.  "Everything is going to change" he said.  "The ordinary people will no longer put up with paying high prices for butter, cheese and meat, just to keep these peasant families in business.'

1983 was a hell of a long time ago and it appears nothing has changed much since then.

[Editor has deleted offensive comment.]

by DeepRed on November 25, 2008
DeepRed

The whole issue brings to mind the protest sculpture by Jens Galschiot known as "Mad Cow Disease", which first appeared near a WTO gathering in Hong Kong in 2005. According to the sculptor's web site:

"A nine metres high pair of scales with a stuffed cow in one arm and five starved African children in the other. A symbol pinpointing that the rich world is using five times the amount of their development aid to support their own agriculture. Each cow in the rich world gets 850 $ in subsidies during its life. "

by on May 08, 2012
Anonymous

Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet If the a lot of simple summer said dressed up, is a bargain Polo Outlet T-shirt with a brace of jeans that go out, both for the accessibility simple, do not breach afresh fashion, a lot of time become abounding adorableness who aboriginal choice;Polo Ralph Lauren Sale Look simple bargain POLOT the T-shirt with jeans, in fact in the Polo T-shirt selected, is aswell charge a lot of mind! Today let Ralph Lauren Men accouterment baby accomplish up for all the girls acclaim a nice and clear bargain Polo T-shirt, let your absorbing a summer!

by on May 18, 2012
Anonymous

people are pursuing for Louis vuitton handbags cool, unique, stylish and innovative. Whether it is discount Louis Vuitton or fashion accessories all means a lot for modern society of today. Same is the case with trendy looking burberry handbags. When these are, the excitement just gets doubled. Most chic looking burberry outlet are in fashion now. These are one of the favorite fashion abercrombie and fitch sale accessories for men and women long time ago. If you have not yet tried Louis Vuitton Outlet, it's time to own one and feel the difference it can make burberry bags to your personality. These are just brilliant and fabulous louis vuitton sale . They are most iconic and can provide burberry bags you with a new feeling and enhance confidence. The quality of louis vuitton online is just superior to what you have dreamt of. Today owning a new and trendy looking louis vuitton bagsare not only meant for the wealthy people. They are most iconic and can provide you with a new feeling and enhance abercrombie and fitch online confidence. The quality of abercrombie sale is just superior to what you have dreamt of. Today owning a new and trendy looking abercrombie outlet sale are not only meant for the wealthy people.

by on May 18, 2012
Anonymous

The newest style of Coach Purses Outlet offer ferragamo bags online. Coach Outlet have cheap Coach Diaper Bags, Coach Hobos Handbags ferragamo handbags, Coach Totes Handbags, Coach Outlet Online for cheap, Coach Poppy Handbags, Coach Outlet Online and Coach wallets. Coach Tote Bags are one of the most popular and versatile handbag styles.are well received by the females, especially the young. Stylish design, colorful painting, practical function attract the public's attention soon. All ferragamo outlet we offer here are stylish trims and innovative designs. Coach Outlet Store Online are mostly welcomed and loved by women and even men. Cheap Coach handbags use the unique and fine leather material which is extraordinary in the world. Take your time to select ferragamo sale our best Coach bags cheap for sale with discount wholesale and free and fast shipping. Online register as a member on this website and enjoy your online shopping. Welcome to enjoy shopping our salvatore ferragamo outlet! Our aim is Best quality top service. Just take action! Don't miss the opportunity to own one of these fasionable Discount Coach Handbags on discounted price. Free shipping and non sale tax! Buy ferragamo shoes now and enjoy the fashion world!

Post new comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.