Obama photo-ops, David Letterman and 'kicking tyres' have taken John Key and his government to giddy heights in the latest Pundit poll of polls. But will ACC and the foreshore taint his gloss?
It seems like the old tactics still work. If your leadership looks to be sagging, head overseas to mix with the good and the great(ly famous). This year, it was John Key travelling to New York and Pundit's poll of polls shows a definite Letterman bump.
Or maybe it was the 'I shook hands with Barack Obama twice' bounce. Or the way the government is constantly "kicking tyres" to avoid looking too radical.
Whatever the reason, National will be fizzing on the back of its polling through September and early October. Where the party had looked to be losing its lustre through a winter of rising unemployment and soggy business confidence, it's shine is back.
The party climbed nearly two points to 56.2 percent and claimed to more seats, according to the Pundit Poll of Polls. With Labour clinging on to just 30 percent support, National's support is almost double that of the Opposition.
Key got great media coverage from his New York trip, with columnists praising his focus on getting closer to America and his networking efforts. He ran through a series of meetings with the leaders of Israel, Turkey, Rwanda and Chile, amongst others, but they got little coverage. It was his brief encounters with President Obama, his speech to the United Nations General Assembly – the first prime minister to speak there since Jim Bolger – and most of all his spot on David Letterman's The Late Show that got attention. You can only assume that New Zealanders still like a bloke who doesn't take himself too seriously and a steady-as-she-goes government.
Of course the government's been boosted by other good news in the past month, most notably the end of the recession, with a slim slice of growth recorded. The national feeling is that the worst is over and the government has seen us through.
Key is untouchable at the moment, but seems to remain cautious and careful to avoid too much public debate. Potential speculation about tax changes have been hurriedly shut down – Key would need a lot of convincing to support a capital gains tax, a flat tax is ruled out, and Bill English doesn't like the look of a GST increase.
Even though he has the political capital to spend, Key has been inclined to keep his Cabinet on a tight leash that doesn't over-reach his mandate from November. His first priority is that second term.
National's policy movements are being tentatively aired via reviews and discussion papers, rather than just announced (consider the health reforms, proposed changes to road rules and mining in national parks). The phrase being used is "kicking the tyres". It's a way to hold your wet finger up in the air to see which way the wind is blowing before actually committing to anything.
When they're ready to act, National is rushing legislation through select committees (as with the ETS law last week) and passing a whopping amount of it under urgency. It seems to be an effective, if cynical, mix of tactics.
On the other side of the House, Phil Goff must be sweating. He's certain National's "gloss" will wear off, and of course it will. But will voters see him as an alternative when it does?
While Goff will be worried by poll averages around 30 percent, there are other falling numbers that will worry him. The Greens have slid a point, leaving the Left looking terribly lean. Even more important, New Zealand First, after a brief flurry of support when Winston Peters announced he would be back for the 2011 election, is on a mere 1.6 percent.
Wise old political heads I've spoken to in recent weeks still give Labour a 50-50 chance of winning in two years. But the uncomfortable truth for Labour is that its success – and Phil Goff's one chance at leading this country – depends on New Zealand First getting back into parliament. It's uncomfortable, even ugly, because Labour will be leaning on Peters' xenophobic impulses.
Goff's hope – and National's risk – over the next few weeks is that the reforms to ACC, its partial privatisation and increased levies will anger a decent chunk of middle-class Kiwis. Perhaps the fact that ACC is in fact world class, financially stable, and out-performs the state schemes in Australia on just about every measure that counts will hit home; maybe New Zealanders will see through the beat-up. But I'm not holding my breath.
The other opportunity for the Opposition is the imminent repeal of the Foreshore and Seabed Act, expected to be announced in early November. Peters will be primed and ready. And once the Maori Party has won its major prize, it will be freer to throw its weight around and the tensions existing between the two parties could inch higher.
Which means John Key must be delighted to look in his diary and see another overseas trip planned. He's off to APEC at the end of the week, where he will catch-up again with his old chum, Barack. More front-page photos guaranteed just when he needs them. Phew, what a relief.


Comments (5)
passing a whopping amount of it under urgency. It seems to be an effective, if cynical, mix of tactics.
Nobody is criticising them for it, so they're getting away with it. The ETS is a bill that concerns $70 billion dollars of future liabilities (at current low carbon prices - look for this to increase substantially), and it's being rammed through under urgency. No political journalists are asking them hard questions about this. Not seriously. They'd rather ask 11 questions about $6000 of overpaid housing allowance.
I'm glad you picked up on that, Tim; I've been thinking about it the last few days, prompted in part by the ETS, but that is only a fraction of the picture. The wider point is verging on abuse of process - Andrew's commented on it already here on Pundit, in what I believe was his first post, that in itself had lots of examples.
When you mention tentative airing of policy, that is sometimes true. And some other times, consultation has been pre-empted so it ends up looking like a bit of a charade. The Maori seats for Auckland (Cabinet announcements pre-select committee report, when select committee had been touted as the public consultation opportunity). The 2020 target consultation (thinly disguised expectation management). When Gerry Brownlee says they're only stock taking in the national parks, and this is nothing to get in a lather about, we're just faciliating an informed conversation, I would say that's a problem of his government's own making: people don't trust the process not to be bent to suit ulterior motives.
The ETS select committee process is the same thing: a hole the government dug for itself, by wasting the whole year on the ETS review. I spied another example in passing today: the Crimes (Provocation Repeal), in which there is high public interest, but no undue urgency, given that people have been recommending repeal since 1976. The result may be right, no question, but first reading was 18 August, and submissions closed 31 August. They received 14.
I've been wondering how one would go about collecting the stats to back this up - to give a basis for saying this government is worse than any other government (or not, as the case may be). It's probably more of an academic than journalistic exercise - I don't even know what you'd take as the measures, because there are a number of possibilities to choose from - but I bet it would be instructive, and anyway, they ought to be at least asked the questions.
Sadly, people seemed to prefer to discuss this elsewhere. But anyway: Idiot Savant has the stats I wanted. Kiwiblog sheds some light on the four different types of urgency. The first half of the post is useful. Never mind the other half; David didn't.
See also: http://www.thestandard.org.nz/whats-so-urgent/
To experience Coach Outlet Online the raising competition and also to gratify the customers, the Coach Outlet brand is providing the latest brand New Coach Handbags. The Coach Outlet offer fashionable designs, stylish style Coach Factory and top quality which are the symbol for all Bags collection from Coach Factory Outlet are loved and enjoyed by people all over the world. For lovers of Coach Outlet brand who love fashion accessories would never miss the Coach Outlet Online. A line of Sac Louis Vuitton are very attractive and pretty certainly. Coach Factory offer Handbags are designed in fashionable way which are on hot sale Coach Outlet Online now. For lovers of Coach Outlet Online brand and for girls who love fashion handbags Coach Factory Online would never miss the Coach Handbag. Large quantities of Coach Purses for women fit your different tastes Coach Outlet Online well. All the women who love fashion and have an eye for nature should come to Coach Outlet to obtain a durable and fashionable Coach bag that harmonize your flair of fashion Coach Outlet! You have a nice chance now! Therefore please feel free to pick up from http://www.mylovecoachoutletonline.org/ the ones you like in our Louis Vuitton pas cher to find the most suitable ones for yourselves.
Post new comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.